18 May 2020
Very Unkind Things about the German Constitutional Court’s Rebellion against the ECJ in the Quantitative Easing Case.
Much has been written about the recent German Constitutional Court (GCC) ruling which has essentially dismantled the 2018 judgement of the European Court of Justice (ECJ) over the legality of the ECB Quantitative Easing Program. Much more will be written. I will limit myself here in analysing what I believe is the “macroeconomic” essence of the ruling. Continue reading >>
2 
17 May 2020
Lehren aus Karlsruhe – die EU-Finanzierung weiterdenken
Das Ultra-Vires-Urteil aus Karlsruhe ist ein weiterer Beleg dafür, dass die Europäische Union in der derzeitigen Strukturierung der Wirtschafts- und Währungsunion nicht zukunftsfähig ist. Eine demokratisch nur dünn legitimierte, aus guten Gründen unabhängige Institution, deren Mandat die Preisstabilität betrifft, zum faktischen Garanten für das finanzielle Überleben der Mitgliedstaaten zu machen, und dieses Überleben ausgerechnet durch eine weitere Ausdehnung der Staatsverschuldung sichern zu wollen, die zudem die Unabhängigkeit der Institution gefährdet, weist in die Irre. Continue reading >>26 March 2020
ESM-Kredite statt Corona-Bonds
ESM-Kredite oder Corona-Bonds? Das Thema steht heute auf der Agenda des Ratstreffens ganz oben. Durch die Corona-Pandemie droht eine wirtschaftliche Krise und eine gemeinsame fiskalische Antwort der Eurozonen-Mitgliedstaaten hierauf wäre ein begrüßenswertes Symbol des Zusammenhalts und der Solidarität in der Europäischen Wirtschafts- und Währungsunion. Sie könnte die Märkte beruhigen, Staatsschuldenkrisen verhindern und Zweifel an der Integrität der Eurozone im Keim ersticken. Diese Antwort muss sich jedoch im Rahmen des geltenden (europäischen Währungs-)Rechts bzw. der Vorgaben des ESM-Vertrages halten. Der Einsatz des ESM ist dabei der Emission von Corona-Bonds vorzuziehen, weil er rechtssicherer und schneller umsetzbar ist. Continue reading >>21 June 2019
Mini-BOTs, complementary currencies and the European monetary malaise
On May 28th, the Italian Chamber of Deputies approved a resolution requiring the government to issue the so-called mini-BOTs. Under such a name, reference is made to Treasury bills issued in small denominations (in Euros), bearing no interest, with no expiry date, and which the Italian Exchequer would accept as a means of payment of taxes. The proposal has been predictably met with marked skepticism by European institutions and by the Italian Minister of Economy and Finance. However, the wisest move, in prudential, political and economic terms, would be that European institutions would embrace experimentation with complementary currencies, in genuine federal spirit. Continue reading >>
0
13 July 2018
Order in the Eurozone: MAURIZIO FERRERA and CLAUS OFFE in Conversation
A German-Italian exchange on the dysfunctionalities of the European Monetary Union and the ongoing social and political crisis particularly in Southern Europe. Continue reading >>07 June 2018
A Crisis Made in Italy
The recent crisis surrounding the Italian President’s refusal to appoint a Finance Minister considered likely to pursue an agenda of ‘Italexit’ has sparked a great deal of constitutional commentary. Two particular threads of opinion are identified here and some doubts cast about them. On the one hand, there are those who consider legitimate the President’s discretionary use of power, partly in light of the pressure that would be brought to bear by the financial markets should Italy opt for exiting the single currency. On the other hand, there are those who doubt its wisdom, and offer a broader indictment of the pressure brought to bear on the Italian government as a result of being in an overly rigid Eurozone. This gets closer to diagnosing the condition, but in its ambiguity about the pressure point, fails to underscore that this is essentially a crisis made in Italy, and, if at all, to be resolved there, including a full and frank debate about membership of the single currency and even the European Union. Continue reading >>26 March 2017
European parliamentary sovereignty on the shoulders of national parliamentary sovereignties: A Reply to Sébastien Platon
We are really grateful that the Verfassungsblog has been one of the very first forums engaging the discussion on the "Treaty on the democratization of the governance of the euro area" (T-Dem). While the proposal has emerged in the framework of the current French presidential campaign, and is now widely debated in this context, it has been primarily thought of as a contribution to the ongoing transnational conversation over the future of the European Union. As authors of the proposal, we first wish to thank our colleague Sébastien Platon for launching an interesting discussion about the T-Dem. Continue reading >>
0
13 March 2017
Democratizing the Euro Area without the European Parliament: Benoît Hamon’s “T-Dem”
On the 10th March, the official candidate of the Socialist Party for the French presidential elections, Benoît Hamon, outlined his programme for the European Union. This programme, whilst being against austerity and in favour of more flexibility as regards EU requirements in terms of public budgets and public debts, comes with a treaty proposal, the draft treaty on the democratization of the governance of the euro area (dubbed « T-Dem »). This treaty, which was prepared by the candidate together with the superstar economist Thomas Piketty (who has joined his team) is supposed to bring more democracy to the governance of the Euro area. However noble (and necessary) this ambitious idea might seem, the way this draft treaty has been engineered raises not only political but also legal questions. Continue reading >>
0
09 December 2016
After the Italian Referendum
So much was at stake for Italy, its political class and its economy, and for the European Union (EU) and its member states in the country’s failed referendum on constitutional reform. In the EU, Germany is a particularly sensitive case. The relations between Germany and Italy are a focal point in Europe. They used to be in an asymmetric, albeit comforting, equilibrium. Continue reading >>22 November 2016